Second Chance Hiring

Second Chance Hiring: A Practical Guide That Actually Works

One in three adults in the United States has a criminal record, yet second chance hiring remains an underutilized strategy for businesses facing talent shortages. When we look at the data, the business case becomes compelling—85% of HR professionals and 81% of business leaders report that employees with criminal records perform just as well or better than their counterparts.

What is second chance hiring exactly? It refers to employment practices that provide opportunities for individuals with criminal records, employment gaps, or other barriers to traditional employment. 

Additionally, companies implementing these second chance hiring programs often offer support systems, training, and mentorship to ensure successful integration. The benefits of second chance hiring extend beyond social good organizations report 25% higher fill rates and 2.7% lower turnover compared to those without such practices. 

In fact, some businesses have seen turnover drop by as much as 70% after implementing second chance hiring practices.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about creating effective second chance hiring practices that work for both your business and potential employees. From securing leadership buy-in to overcoming common challenges, we’ll provide practical steps to tap into this overlooked talent pool.

What is Second Chance Hiring?

Second chance hiring represents a fundamental shift in employment practices. This approach involves hiring individuals with criminal records after evaluating them as whole persons rather than automatically disqualifying them based on past mistakes. 

Unlike traditional hiring models, second chance hiring recognizes that previous involvement with the justice system shouldn’t permanently exclude qualified candidates from meaningful employment opportunities.

Definition and core principles

At its core, second chance hiring goes beyond basic compliance with fair hiring laws. The practice centers on creating intentional pathways for workforce re-entry. Instead of making snap judgments based on criminal history, employers examine the relevance of prior convictions to the position. 

For example, if someone has a driving-related conviction but the job requires no driving, that conviction may not be relevant to their ability to perform.

The philosophy behind second chance hiring balances both practical business considerations and social responsibility. This approach involves:

• Evaluating candidates individually rather than with blanket policies
• Focusing on skills and qualifications over background history
• Providing support systems including training and mentorship
• Creating an inclusive environment that values growth and rehabilitation

Many organizations have formalized these principles into structured second chance hiring programs. These initiatives often include partnerships with reentry organizations and modified application processes that prioritize current capabilities over past mistakes.

Who qualifies for second chance hiring

Second chance hiring primarily focuses on justice-impacted individuals—people with criminal records who face significant barriers to employment. Each year, more than 650,000 individuals exit the justice system and seek to rebuild their lives. However, these candidates represent just one segment of those who benefit from second chance approaches.

The broader category often includes people experiencing:

• Criminal conviction history (ranging from minor offenses to more serious crimes)
• Long periods of unemployment or significant employment gaps
• Other systemic barriers to traditional employment paths

Nevertheless, not all criminal histories are considered equal in the hiring process. Many employers use individualized assessments that consider factors such as the nature of the offense, its relevance to the specific job, and the time elapsed since conviction. Since most recidivism happens within the first three years after release, older convictions may have minimal relevance to current employment potential.

Why it matters in today’s job market

The significance of second chance hiring extends far beyond social good—it addresses critical business needs in an evolving labor market. With one in three Americans having either an arrest or conviction record, excluding this population significantly reduces the available talent pool during persistent labor shortages.

From an economic perspective, the impact is substantial. The employment barriers faced by people with criminal records result in an estimated loss between $78 billion and $87 billion in annual gross domestic product. Moreover, without stable employment, formerly incarcerated individuals face higher risks of returning to prison—a costly cycle for both individuals and society.

Second chance hiring directly addresses the problem of recidivism. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, 68% of released prisoners are rearrested within three years. However, stable employment has proven to be one of the most effective ways to break this cycle, reducing the likelihood of re-incarceration by approximately 14-25%.

For businesses facing recruitment challenges, this approach offers practical benefits. Organizations implementing second chance hiring have reported significant improvements, including:

• 25% higher fill rates for open positions
• 2.7% lower overall turnover compared to businesses without such practices
• Up to 70% reduction in turnover in some cases
• Enhanced workforce diversity and stronger community connections

Beyond the numbers, second chance hiring reflects an evolving understanding that past mistakes shouldn’t determine future potential. As more businesses discover the advantages of this approach, it continues gaining momentum across industries from retail giants like Walmart and Home Depot to financial institutions like JPMorgan Chase.

Why Businesses Should Care

“85% of human resources leaders and 81% of business leaders say that second chance hires perform the same or better than other employees.” — U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Leading business advocacy organization

Beyond social responsibility, second chance hiring makes remarkable business sense. Forward-thinking companies are discovering compelling advantages that directly impact their bottom line through this approach.

Access to untapped talent pools

With nearly 80 million Americans—approximately 25% of the U.S. population—having a criminal record, businesses overlook an enormous talent reservoir when using traditional candidate screening methods. Even if every currently unemployed person was hired, over a million jobs would still remain unfilled. This represents a critical opportunity for employers facing talent shortages.

Each year, approximately 448,000 individuals exit prison searching for employment opportunities. Most importantly, these candidates aren’t just available—they’re often exceptionally motivated. At Toyota’s manufacturing plant in Georgetown, KY, implementing second chance hiring expanded their talent pool by an impressive 20%. Furthermore, their overall workforce diversity increased by 8%.

Companies implementing fair chance hiring programs report fill rates 25% higher than those without such practices. This advantage proves especially valuable during persistent labor shortages across industries. As JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon notes, “Business has an important role to play in making it easier for people with criminal backgrounds to get back on their feet”.

Improved employee loyalty and retention

Perhaps the most compelling business case for second chance hiring comes from remarkable retention data. Organizations consistently report that employees with criminal records demonstrate exceptional loyalty and work ethic.

The evidence is substantial:

• Toyota’s second chance program reduced turnover by an astonishing 70% to just 3% monthly
• Companies with second chance hiring practices experience turnover rates 2.7% lower than those without
• Mercury Plastics reports 80% retention among second-chance hires compared to 60% for traditional hires

These statistics translate into significant cost savings. Consider that 85% of HR professionals and 81% of business leaders report that individuals with criminal records perform the same as or better than employees without criminal records. Additionally, 82% of managers say the value these employees bring is as high as or higher than workers without records.

The loyalty factor cannot be overstated. According to research from New York University’s Mandel Center, companies actively hiring formerly incarcerated individuals see increased employee loyalty and reduced turnover, saving substantial costs associated with recruiting and training. Some studies suggest these inclusive hiring policies can boost employee retention by 20-30%.

Positive brand reputation and social impact

Adopting second chance hiring practices significantly enhances corporate image among both consumers and potential employees. Around 60% of consumers are more likely to support brands that promote diversity and social responsibility. Consequently, companies implementing these programs often experience improved corporate reputation/ employer brand.

Internal culture also benefits substantially. Approximately 66% of employees report feeling proud to work for organizations offering training and mentorship to people with criminal records. This creates a positive ripple effect throughout the entire workforce.

The financial incentives are equally compelling. Through the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC), employers can receive tax incentives up to $9,600 per eligible employee. On a broader scale, addressing employment barriers for those with criminal records could add between $78 billion and $87 billion annually to the U.S. economy.

Beyond direct business benefits, second chance hiring strengthens communities by reducing recidivism. Employment is proven to decrease reoffending by approximately 14-25%. This creates safer communities while simultaneously addressing talent shortages—a genuine win-win situation.

As Kelly Services CEO Peter Quigley observed after implementing their successful “Kelly 33” program: “The reality is, most Americans want people who have a blemish on their criminal record to get another chance. They want to work with companies that have those programs, and they want to work for companies that have those opportunities”.

Key Benefits of Second Chance Hiring

“Companies that have adapted their culture to support second chance employees are finding that their overall workforce is becoming more engaged and likely to stay with the company.” — U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Leading business advocacy organization

The tangible benefits of second chance hiring extend far beyond goodwill. Companies embracing this approach report specific, measurable advantages that directly impact their bottom line.

Lower turnover and recruitment costs

The financial case for second chance hiring is compelling, primarily through remarkable employee retention. Organizations implementing second chance programs have experienced turnover reductions of up to 70%. This dramatic improvement translates into substantial savings, considering the high costs associated with recruiting, onboarding, and training replacement employees.

Data consistently validates the performance of these hires. Research demonstrates that 85% of human resources leaders and 81% of business leaders report that employees with criminal records perform the same as or better than other employees. This contradicts common misconceptions about hiring justice-involved individuals.

Second chance employers often report faster hiring processes and reduced recruitment costs when partnering with re-entry organizations that provide pre-screened, employment-ready candidates. Essentially, these partnerships create pipelines of motivated talent while simultaneously reducing traditional recruitment expenses.

Tax incentives and government support

Beyond operational benefits, organizations implementing second chance hiring can access significant financial incentives. The Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) offers employers substantial tax savings for hiring qualified individuals with criminal records.

Key WOTC benefits include:

• 40% tax credit on up to $9,600 of first-year wages for employees working 400+ hours
• 25% tax credit for employees working between 120-399 hours
• Ability to carry unused credits forward for up to 20 years

The Federal Bonding Program provides additional support by offering fidelity bonds protecting employers against employee dishonesty in the first six months at no cost. These bonds cover between $5,000 and $25,000 for issues like employee theft, forgery, and embezzlement.

Certain countries offer additional support programs. For instance, some governments have introduced credits like the Uplifting Employment Credit, providing time-limited wage offsets to employers hiring ex-offenders. These programs typically provide thousands of dollars in annual support per qualifying employee.

Diversity and inclusion advancement

Undeniably, second chance hiring enhances workplace diversity and inclusion initiatives. With one in three Black men having a felony conviction, companies committed to hiring formerly incarcerated individuals are investing in chronically underserved communities. This approach helps organizations build more representative workforces while addressing historical inequities.

The diversity benefits extend beyond demographics. Employees with varied life experiences contribute unique perspectives that enhance problem-solving capabilities and decision-making processes. Organizations with inclusive hiring practices develop stronger adaptability as diverse teams navigate challenges more effectively than homogeneous groups.

Subsequently, these diversity efforts positively impact both internal culture and external perception. Research indicates that 66% of employees express pride in working for companies that offer training, guidance, or mentorship to individuals with criminal records. This pride translates into stronger employee engagement throughout the organization.

The combined financial, operational, and cultural benefits of second chance hiring create a compelling business case that complements the social impact. For organizations seeking measurable returns on their diversity and inclusion efforts, second chance hiring delivers quantifiable results.

How to Build a Second Chance Hiring Program

Implementing a successful second chance hiring program requires strategic planning and thoughtful execution. Following a structured approach ensures your organization can effectively tap into this talent pool while setting up both your business and new employees for success.

Step 1: Get leadership buy-in

Creating meaningful change starts at the top. Initially, develop a compelling business case that presents second chance hiring as a strategic talent solution, not merely a charitable initiative. Prior to approaching executives, prepare a written proposal that outlines:

• Financial benefits including tax incentives and reduced turnover costs
• Data showing that 85% of HR leaders report second chance hires perform as well as or better than other employees
• Clear policies defining which types of backgrounds you’ll consider and any exclusions

Notably, research shows getting buy-in from an executive stakeholder makes post-pilot rollout significantly easier. Throughout this process, communicate transparently with existing employees about your intentions, allowing them to raise questions or concerns before implementation.

Step 2: Review and update hiring policies

Following leadership approval, conduct an organizational readiness assessment to identify positions suitable for second chance hiring. Review existing policies to remove unnecessary barriers while maintaining appropriate safety measures.

Beyond elimination of blanket exclusions, develop individualized assessment procedures that evaluate:

• Job relevance of any conviction
• Time elapsed since the offense
• Evidence of rehabilitation and skill development
• Current qualifications and potential

Although standardized background checks remain important, modify their application by implementing “skill assessments” that level the playing field and reduce bias. First and foremost, ensure all policy changes comply with fair hiring laws and regulations by collaborating with your legal department.

Step 3: Partner with reentry organizations

Specialized community partnerships provide invaluable support for second chance hiring success. Generally, these organizations offer pre-screening, training, and ongoing support that significantly reduce implementation challenges.

When selecting partner organizations, consider these evaluation criteria:

1. Track record of successful placements
2. Quality of pre-employment training
3. Post-hiring support services
4. Understanding of your industry’s requirements
5. Ability to provide ongoing mentorship

Organizations like GEO Reentry Connect and programs such as Reentry Works specifically connect employers with qualified candidates. Yet another approach is attending job fairs focused on second-chance employment opportunities to establish connections with potential candidates directly.

Step 4: Train hiring managers and teams

Comprehensive training represents the foundation of sustainable second chance hiring. Before launching your program, develop training modules addressing:

• Fair hiring practices and unconscious bias recognition
• Effective interviewing techniques for candidates with criminal histories
• Best practices for onboarding and integration
• Clear communication about company policies and expectations

After implementing training, provide hiring managers with structured interview questions designed to assess candidates holistically, focusing on rehabilitation journeys and future potential rather than past mistakes. Educate team members about the business case for second chance hiring to address misconceptions and create a welcoming environment.

Primarily, remember that successful implementation isn’t about lowering standards—it’s about widening access and evaluating potential more effectively. By taking a thoughtful, structured approach to building your second chance hiring program, you can create opportunities that benefit both your business and individuals seeking a fresh start.

Overcoming Common Challenges

Despite compelling benefits, implementing second chance hiring comes with obstacles that require thoughtful solutions. Many organizations face similar challenges when establishing these programs, yet practical strategies exist to overcome them successfully.

Addressing safety and risk concerns

Many employers hesitate to hire individuals with criminal records due to misconceptions about safety risks. In reality, research reveals that the risk of negligent hiring liability is far less common than widely perceived. Over a 48-year period, only approximately 47 cases per year involved employers being held liable for negligent hiring.

Studies indicate that nearly all liability cases (97%) involved positions with specific risks, such as:

• Contact with vulnerable populations
• Operation of motor vehicles
• Access to financial assets or homes
• Use of force or firearms

For most office and factory jobs, negligent hiring liability risk remains minimal. Employers can effectively manage these concerns through role-specific risk assessments that evaluate whether a candidate’s history actually relates to job functions. Indeed, employers who conduct thorough background checks and properly evaluate results are rarely held liable.

Navigating legal and compliance issues

The legal landscape around second chance hiring has evolved considerably. Currently, more than 35 states and 150 municipalities have enacted “ban-the-box” laws regulating when and how criminal history can be considered—typically delaying such inquiries until after a conditional job offer.

Federal law explicitly prohibits blanket policies denying employment to individuals with arrest and conviction histories. The EEOC has taken action against companies using such approaches, with some businesses required to pay over $6.75 million to settle cases.

To maintain compliance, HR teams should treat criminal record information as confidential, similar to medical conditions. Meanwhile, organizations should still communicate transparently about their second chance hiring initiatives with current employees to build understanding and support.

Changing internal culture and bias

Internal resistance often stems from unconscious bias rather than legitimate concerns. Unconscious bias against underrepresented groups can prevent companies from finding exceptional talent and potentially costs businesses significant revenue.

To overcome these challenges:

First and foremost, provide education about the differences between violent and nonviolent offenses, or between recent and historical convictions. Structured interviews represent an effective method to reduce hiring bias by ensuring all candidates answer the same questions and are evaluated against consistent criteria.

Consider implementing blind screening periods where identifying information about criminal history is temporarily removed during initial evaluations. Admittedly, this approach requires commitment, yet structured assessments help ensure decisions are based on measurable factors rather than subjective impressions.

Ultimately, successful second chance hiring programs begin with leadership. When executives actively support hiring talented candidates of all backgrounds and establish standards that eliminate impediments, long-term change becomes possible.

Best Practices for Long-Term Success

Creating sustainable second chance hiring programs requires going beyond initial implementation to focus on practices that ensure long-term success. These foundational elements help both employees and organizations thrive through thoughtful integration and support.

Use skill-based assessments

Skill-based assessments provide an objective way to evaluate candidates based on capabilities rather than background. Companies adopting these assessments find them particularly effective for second chance hiring as they focus on what candidates can actually do versus what they claim on resumes. Approximately 82% of organizations now use some form of skill assessment tools in their hiring processes.

These assessments offer multiple advantages:

• They reduce unconscious bias by standardizing evaluation criteria
• They highlight capabilities that might otherwise be overlooked
• They help match candidates to positions where they’ll excel

Employers using skills data to find the right match are 60% more likely to make successful hires than those not relying on skills. Furthermore, companies transitioning to skills-based approaches report expectations of increased profitability and growth.

Provide mentorship and onboarding support

Pairing new second chance hires with mentors dramatically improves integration and retention. Organizations implementing mentorship programs report higher employee retention rates and improved productivity. These relationships help new employees navigate workplace challenges while building confidence.

Effective mentorship covers crucial areas like CV writing, interview preparation, building confidence, and addressing workplace queries. Programs typically last 6-9 months with regular check-ins to address concerns and provide support.

Thoughtful onboarding proves equally important—teaching not only job requirements but company culture and expectations. This initial investment helps new employees integrate quickly and feel valued from day one.

Track performance and retention metrics

Measuring success requires collecting relevant data on retention and performance. Organizations should regularly conduct feedback sessions to identify what works and areas for improvement. This information helps refine second chance hiring programs over time.

When tracking metrics, focus on turnover rates, job performance, and career advancement. Successful companies consistently report that employees with criminal records perform as well or better than those without such backgrounds.

Celebrate success stories internally

Sharing success stories creates powerful validation for your second chance hiring program. Real examples of individuals who’ve thrived after being given an opportunity inspire colleagues and leadership. One organization found employees going from supervisory roles to office positions, becoming “beacons of hope” for newer hires.

These narratives help demonstrate that second chance hiring isn’t just charity—it’s good business. They additionally provide concrete examples of program success while helping change perceptions throughout the organization.

Conclusion

Second chance hiring represents far more than a social initiative—it offers a powerful business strategy that addresses talent shortages while changing lives. Throughout this guide, we’ve seen compelling evidence that formerly incarcerated individuals often become exceptionally loyal and productive employees. Additionally, companies implementing these programs report remarkable benefits: 25% higher fill rates, significantly lower turnover, and access to an overlooked talent pool of millions.

Starting a second chance hiring program certainly requires thoughtful planning. Leadership buy-in, updated policies, strategic partnerships, and proper training form the foundation for success. Still, the potential rewards—both financial and cultural—make the investment worthwhile.

Perhaps most importantly, these programs create opportunities for individuals who genuinely deserve another chance. When companies look beyond past mistakes to evaluate current capabilities, they discover talented people eager to prove themselves. After all, everyone benefits when qualified candidates find meaningful employment regardless of their background.

Remember that successful implementation doesn’t happen overnight. Companies must balance legitimate safety considerations with fair evaluation practices. Undoubtedly, providing mentorship and using skill-based assessments rather than relying solely on background checks will improve outcomes substantially.

Though challenges exist, the data speaks for itself—second chance hiring works. Forward-thinking organizations already recognize this untapped potential, gaining competitive advantages while strengthening communities. Whether your company faces persistent talent shortages or simply wants to build a more diverse workforce, second chance hiring offers a practical solution that actually delivers results.

Key Takeaways

Second chance hiring isn’t just about social responsibility—it’s a proven business strategy that addresses talent shortages while delivering measurable results. Here are the essential insights for organizations considering this approach:

• Tap into overlooked talent: With 80 million Americans having criminal records, second chance hiring expands your talent pool by 25% while achieving higher fill rates than traditional hiring methods.

• Boost retention dramatically: Companies report up to 70% lower turnover rates among second chance hires, with 85% of HR leaders confirming these employees perform as well or better than others.

• Access financial incentives: The Work Opportunity Tax Credit provides up to $9,600 per eligible employee, while reduced recruitment and training costs create additional savings.

• Start with leadership buy-in: Successful programs require executive support, updated hiring policies, partnerships with reentry organizations, and comprehensive team training to overcome bias.

• Focus on skills over history: Use individualized assessments and skill-based evaluations rather than blanket exclusions to identify qualified candidates while maintaining appropriate safety measures.

The evidence is clear: second chance hiring creates win-win outcomes for businesses seeking loyal employees and individuals deserving meaningful opportunities to rebuild their lives.

FAQs

Curious about more HR buzzwords like interview-to-hire ratio, behavioral interview, casual leave, leave encashment, relieving letter, resignation letter or more? Dive into our HR Glossary and get clear definitions of the terms that drive modern HR.

Explore Taggd for RPO solutions.