1. What Is the Typical Cost of Using a Recruitment Agency?
This is always one of the first questions, and for good reason: what’s the investment? There’s no single price tag because the cost really depends on the agency’s model and how complex the role is that you’re trying to fill. Generally, you’ll run into two main fee structures: contingency and retained search.
Contingency Fees: This is the most common setup, especially for junior to mid-level roles. The fee is simply a percentage of the candidate’s first-year salary, usually somewhere between 15% and 25%. The best part? You only pay if you actually hire someone the agency brings to you. It’s a classic “no win, no fee” deal.
Retained Search Fees: When you’re looking for senior leaders or the search is highly confidential, a retained model is the standard. Here, the fee is also a percentage of the salary (often a bit higher, from 25% to 35%), but it’s paid in stages. You’ll typically pay an upfront retainer, another instalment when they present a shortlist of candidates, and the final amount when the hire is made. This model secures a dedicated, exclusive search effort just for you.
2. How Long Does It Take to Fill a Position?
How quickly a role gets filled can vary a lot, but one thing is almost certain: a good agency will speed up the process. While an average in-house hiring timeline can easily stretch from 45 to 60 days, a focused agency can often slice that time down considerably.
A few things will influence the speed:
Role Complexity: Finding a great sales executive will naturally be quicker than hunting for a highly specialised machine learning engineer with a niche skillset.
Market Conditions: If the talent you need is scarce, the search is simply going to take longer. That’s just the reality of the market.
Client Responsiveness: This is a big one. The speed at which you provide feedback on candidates and set up interviews plays a huge role. An engaged client helps the agency keep the momentum going.
A top-notch agency can tap into their existing talent pools and focused resources to present a shortlist of qualified candidates, often within just one to two weeks. This dramatically cuts down the time you’d spend on initial sourcing and screening.
3. How Do You Ensure Confidentiality for Sensitive Hires?
Confidentiality is everything, especially when you’re filling a key leadership role or replacing an incumbent who isn’t yet aware of the change. This is where retained executive search firms really shine. Discretion is their bread and butter.
The whole process is built around carefully controlled communication. Recruiters will never mention your company’s name in their initial outreach. Instead, they’ll present a confidential “opportunity profile” to pique the interest of potential candidates. Only after a candidate has been thoroughly vetted and signs a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) is your organisation’s identity revealed. This multi-layered approach keeps your search completely under wraps and protects your company’s privacy.